You unlock your phone to check the time, and somehow land in Instagram. One Reddit user described exactly that after a week of grayscale. This post collects what people say actually stuck when they tried to make their phone less distracting, what the studies found, and the Android settings that can help, named the way Google names them.
If you have searched for how to reduce screen time or stop using your phone, or read about phone addiction, you have probably met two tips: grayscale and turning off notifications. We start there, because people's experience with both is mixed.
Grayscale: a nudge that often fades
None of the people quoted here are connected to FIVE, and nothing on this page says they use it.
Grayscale turns your screen black and white. On Android it is one of the options in Digital Wellbeing's Bedtime mode, which can turn on while your phone charges at night.
The one study we found is small. Researchers tracked 84 people's phone use for two weeks: a normal week, then a week in grayscale. Daily screen time fell by about 20 minutes, but the number of times people unlocked their phones did not change, which the researchers read as a sign of "deep-rooted checking habits".
People disagree about it. On Hacker News, one person gave up within an hour because they needed color to show someone a photo, and another had kept it for almost a month when they wrote. A third found that one week in, "my screen time was back to the baseline". A reply on Reddit put the problem in one line:
"Grayscale did nothing for me either."
"I think it changes what the phone looks like and not what the hand does."
Some people say a gentler version helps: grayscale only at night. One Reddit user has it switch on from midnight to eight in the morning, and says that turning it off "takes an extra step", so they more often just go to sleep.
Turning off notifications, except calls and texts
In the threads we read, most people end up in the same place: calls and texts get through, and little else. One Reddit user keeps "calls, messages (text) and bank apps" and nothing else. On Hacker News, one person turned off everything except SMS and phone calls, and deleted social media apps:
"I did this 8 years ago and I can't recall anything important that I have missed."
The one proper trial we found does not back the simple story, though. In a preregistered randomized trial of 205 people, turning notifications off for a week did not change how often people checked their phones or their screen time. It did make checking feel more intentional, and it raised fear of missing out.
People split the same way. One Reddit user keeps notifications on, because with them off "i constantly check in the app". Silence has a cost too: the person who started the Hacker News thread quoted above often silences their phone, and missed the reminder for their closest friend's birthday.
Android offers middle ground. You can turn off an app's notifications or only some categories, or make them Silent: no sound or vibration, but they still show when you swipe down. Modes and Do Not Disturb let chosen People and Apps through, and Allow repeat callers lets a call through if the same person calls twice in 15 minutes (some of these settings need Android 14 or later, and settings vary by phone).
Put a step between you and the phone
In the threads we read, this is the change people most often say stuck. The Reddit user who still opened Instagram in grayscale found something else that worked:
"What actually slowed me down was putting the phone in a drawer while I cooked dinner."
"Just one meal. First night I checked the drawer twice. Second night once. By Thursday I finished cooking without thinking about it."
The bedroom is where many people try it. One Reddit user wrote: "If my phone is physically in the room it tugs at me. I must leave it charging in another room." In a US local TV news story from April 2026, Courtney Lindwall of Consumer Reports advised, "Start by just taking short breaks," and named a phone in another room as one way. The story cites no study. People who use the phone as an alarm mention a basic alarm clock or a watch instead.
It is not for everyone. In a 2026 Reddit thread on the bedroom rule, one reply said simply: "Nah, doesn't make a difference to me." Another person is on call at night and cannot risk missing the phone. If you need it near you, experts quoted by The Straits Times suggest switching it to Do Not Disturb; on Android, Do Not Disturb can still let chosen People through.
And buying the gear is not the same as doing it: one person on Mastodon bought an alarm clock and wrote that the phone was "still right next to me."
Let someone else hold the passcode
Limits you set for yourself are easy to undo: Google's own help page says you can delete an app timer to use the app again before it resets at midnight. In a preprint of four studies (not yet peer reviewed), young adults asked to keep social media to 30 or 60 minutes a day often did not stick to it; the authors call it "low adherence to time limits". Even with daily reminders, in the fourth study "close to 95% of participants still failed to adhere".
So some people hand the key to someone else. Several people on Hacker News have a partner or friend set the iPhone Screen Time passcode:
"Still possible to override with your Apple ID, but this is a significant enough speed bump that it works (for me anyway)."
A Reddit post from July 2026 gives the same advice: "Ask them to choose a random passcode and not tell you what it is." On Android, the closest built-in tool is the App limits PIN in Digital Wellbeing, which stops app limits being changed without it. None of our sources tested handing that PIN to someone else.
A small delay can help too. University of Michigan researchers tested an Android app that interferes with taps and swipes against one that locks you out. In a five-week field study with 42 people, around 62% kept the gentle version on for the day, against 36% for the lockout, according to the university's news release.
Take the worst apps off the phone
One of the top answers in a Reddit thread about small changes was this:
"Getting apps off of my phone and only checking them when I feel like it on my computer."
"All the platforms feel less addictive when I'm looking at them on desktop version."
An India-based writer for Make Tech Easier said apps and tools were not enough on their own; deleting social apps from the phone and keeping the iPad in another room worked better. Others make the home screen plain, with few apps or a text-only launcher. As one Hacker News commenter put it: "The idea is to make your Phone boring but just works when you need it."
One catch: the time can move somewhere else. A user on r/IndiaTech said that after buying a laptop, their phone screen time fell but their laptop screen time went above 8 hours a day.
Why a basic phone is hard: an example from India
Some people who consider a basic phone find how much of daily life runs through their smartphone. India gives one clear example, with its UPI payment apps. One r/IndiaTech post said: "i want to switch to dumbphone but the only thing that is stopping me is upi apps." In another thread, a reply put it plainly:
"it's harder to switch to dumb phones in India where most of the things (payment, train pass, Digital ID, etc) are on mobile.."
Another reply asked how you would pay at shops, buy tickets or file your tax return, and the post itself named losing WhatsApp as the biggest worry. A 2022 explainer from The Quint says UPI 123Pay lets basic phones make UPI payments without the internet, but that scan and pay is not available on it.
It is not only an India story. Bea, a 37-year-old from London, said in The Guardian in 2024 that she chose a basic phone because it has WhatsApp, and that "it's too complicated to live life without it".
The compromise people suggest is to keep the smartphone but strip it down, with an Android app blocker that locks it to the apps you pick, or a minimalist launcher that shows a plain list of app names. Notifications can have a catch there too. One r/IndiaTech user said in November 2024 that they had turned off every unimportant notification, but that GPay sent payment alerts and promotions under one switch: "Its either turn on all notification or turn off all notification."
Start with one moment
Most of these reports come from people who chose to post on Reddit and tech forums, and none of the studies we found followed anyone for more than a few weeks. So treat them as ideas to try, not rules. One Reddit poster's advice was to pick a single moment, like the first grab of the morning, and build from there:
"Trying to fix everything at once is how you get overwhelmed and quit."
And have something to reach for instead. The Hacker News commenter whose grayscale faded after a week ended on this: "Put the phone down and replace it with a book, or puzzles, or hobbies, or time with people."
About FIVE
We make FIVE, an Android app that covers distracting apps for a time you choose, while the apps you need stay one tap away. You can start it now or schedule it for later. FIVE is on Google Play for Android: Get it on Google Play. It was not part of any study or thread quoted on this page.
Sources
Quotes and facts below were read on 13 October 2026 and come from the research file for this post. Reddit pages were read through the Arctic Shift archive, a public copy of Reddit posts and comments, because Reddit blocked our server; the links go to the original Reddit pages. Official pages change, so treat this list as a dated snapshot.
- Google, Android Help (undated page): Control notifications on Android. Read on 13 October 2026.
- Google, Android Help (undated page): Manage how you spend time on your Android phone with Digital Wellbeing. Read on 13 October 2026.
- Google, Android Help (undated page): Limit interruptions with Modes & Do Not Disturb on Android. Read on 13 October 2026.
- C.A. Dekker and S.E. Baumgartner, Mobile Media & Communication, September 2024: Is life brighter when your phone is not? (abstract). Read on 13 October 2026.
- C.A. Dekker, S.E. Baumgartner, S.R. Sumter and J. Ohme, Media Psychology, 2025: Beyond the Buzz (abstract). Read on 13 October 2026.
- Abigail Bradley and others, PsyArXiv preprint, version of 27 May 2026: Is Limiting Social Media Use Feasible for Young Adults? A 4-Study Replication Failure of a Screen Time Reduction Intervention (abstract; not peer reviewed). Read on 13 October 2026.
- Kate McAlpine, University of Michigan, via Futurity, 28 May 2024: Making your phone annoying may get you to cut screen time. Read on 13 October 2026.
- Hacker News thread, 21 December 2025: Go Gray, Not Cray: Why You Should Grayscale Your Phone (comments). Read on 13 October 2026.
- Hacker News thread, 27 January 2026: Ask HN: Notification Overload (a post and a comment). Read on 13 October 2026.
- Hacker News thread, 8 September 2025: iPhone dumbphone (comments). Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/nosurf, 17 September 2026: put my phone on grayscale for a week and still opened ig like six times a day (post, and a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 17 March 2025: Grayscale changed my perception of reality (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 4 October 2025: Are your non-essential notifications 'off/blocked' or 'on silent'? (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 23 March 2026: Turning off notifications works or not? (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 6 October 2024: Did you sleep better after removing phone from the bedroom? (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- Brittany Morgan, WSLS 10 (Roanoke, US), 24 April 2026: Simple steps to help slash daily screen time (a short local TV news story that quotes Courtney Lindwall of Consumer Reports). Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 13 December 2025: Not keeping my phone in my bedroom has been huge. (post, and a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 29 July 2026: Has keeping your phone out of the bedroom actually improved your sleep? (replies). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- The Straits Times, via the Singapore General Hospital newsroom, 29 June 2026: Is your phone keeping you awake? 4 tips for sleep-deprived S'poreans. Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Mastodon user (berlin.social), 26 March 2026: post. Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 27 July 2026: iOS Screen Time is all you need. Here's how to set it up so you cannot simply tap Ignore limit and bypass it.. Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/digitalminimalism, 19 November 2025: What small digital changes (settings, habits, decluttering tricks) have improved your mental wellbeing the most? (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- Abhimanyu Ghoshal, Make Tech Easier, 2 April 2024: How I'm Finally Reducing My Screen Time in 2024. Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/IndiaTech, 27 February 2026: How you guys are managing your screentime, please give me some tips. (a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/IndiaTech, 11 June 2024: Switching to Dumbphone to reduce screentime (post, and a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/IndiaTech, 16 June 2026: Is it worth switching from iPhone to Nokia dumbphone? Only thing killing me is losing WhatsApp (replies). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- The Quint, 15 March 2022: UPI 123Pay Launched For Feature Phones: How to Make Payments?. Read on 13 October 2026.
- Clea Skopeliti, The Guardian, 12 June 2024: 'We need to go places and touch things': the people turning away from smartphones (the profile of Bea). Read on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/IndiaTech, 25 November 2024: Wtf... i don't want promotional notifications from gpay. Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
- A Reddit user on r/nosurf, 20 December 2025: I got so tired of app blockers, grayscale, timers.. I did this instead (post, and a reply). Read via the Arctic Shift archive copy on 13 October 2026.
Pictures (licenses read on each Wikimedia Commons file page on 13 October 2026):
- Top: pixellaphoto / www.Pixel.la Free Stock Photos, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons - file page
- Grayscale: Julian Murillo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons - file page
- Alarm clock: Danielrayyan09, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons - file page
- Home screen: Gannu03, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons - file page
- Basic phones: Kskhh, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons - file page
Keep reading
- What to do instead of scrolling: ideas for real-life breaks Long lists of hobbies can miss the moment you actually reach for your phone. These ideas, drawn from news reports, studies and people's own posts, are matched to that moment: a few spare minutes, an evening at home, a wish to read or a wish for company.
- People who chose to use their phone less Christopher Nolan uses a flip phone. P. V. Sindhu, by her own account, went three months without hers. Here is what each of them said, with a link to where they said it, and an even-handed list of tools that can help if you want to use your phone less too.
- Screen time vs screen on time: what your phone counts Your phone shows more than one screen time number, and they often do not match. Here is what Digital Wellbeing and the battery screen each count, where the sources disagree or say nothing, and how to use the numbers if you want to use your phone less.